Monday, August 4, 2008

Recovery of Chek Jawa thus far

5am, one small team of us left Changi jetty, volunteering selflessly to do a health check at Chek Jawa. Though all of my regular gang were busy to make it, I am very grateful that Ginny, Pamela, Tze Hwee and Han Sheng could come and help put and also experience Chek Jawa for their first time.


It has been one year since I've arrived at Chek Jawa so early. But we get to enjoy the spectacular sunrise over the horizon of Pulau Tekong.

This stretch of Chek Jawa to the west of the coral rubble, near the House No. 1 jetty has very good growths and large numbers of adult carpet anemones (Stichodactyla haddoni).


It is postulated that this part of Chek Jawa seemed to have minimal freshwater impacts due to headlands that diverted the river effect from Johor River. Therefore, numerous carpet anemones are still thriving here and that this location also acts as a seeding site for recovery to the other parts of Chek Jawa.


The way they are found on the seagrass area of this part of Chek Jawa can come in random, clusters,


and interestingly, linear fashion, where five of them forms a straight line. I guess this is just purely coincidental.


But it is also possible that the carpet anemones here could be migrated from the other parts of Chek Jawa that were badly affected by the Jan 2007 mass death.


This is because they can uproot themselves in stressful situations and drift with the currents to a less stressful area.


However, I couldn't find the colourful variety of sponges at the coral rubble that I've seen before during December 07. Only many of these long branched purple sponges, as also observed by Ria earlier on, can be found.


According to our regular trips observation from northern shores, these long branched purple sponges are very common because they are quite tough and can be found even in inconducive conditions. What happen to the other "more sensitive" sponges? Was the tide not low enough to reveal the other sponges?


Ginny and I were doing checks at the coral rubble, one of which is to find the adult knobbly sea stars (Protoreaster nodosus). I think the tide wasn't super low enough (though 0.0m) to find the adults. But Ginny found this juvenile knobbly sea star that was enough to make me excited.


This means new blood of the knobbly stars for Chek Jawa! Can't wait for them to grow up.


Other sea stars spotted included a couple of the cake sea stars (Anthenea aspera).


This is the other cake sea star found at the coral rubble area.


As usual, there are many biscuit sea stars (Goniodiscaster scaber) that we commonly find at the northern shores nowadays.


I've also found a patch of zebra coral (Oulastrea sp.) growing in the interior of an abandon tyre.

Also spotted are zoanthids and flowery soft corals that I couldn't take a photo of due to the murky waters from the returning tides.

Next, we checked the sand bar and the seagrass lagoon area.


Several groundscape photographs were taken for monitoring over time and also to compare with the state of Chek Jawa before the mass death.

Tze Hwee, alone, was posted to search for the Button Shells (Umbonium vestiarum) at a far far northern sandbar. She couldn't find them though, even at the usual spots where I once recorded GPS points.


While everyone was hard at work, Pamela and Han Sheng were searching for the mussel beds within the seagrass lagoon.


To my surprise, we could not find any mussel bed today! This was in line with the missing mussel beds from Changi and also later on I realized those at the Ubin jetty were gone too. What was left behind were the mounds of mud that I believed were once trapped by the byssus threads of the once-existent mussels. Could their absence now be due to a seasonal reason or that the predators of these Asian mussels (Musculista senhousia) have completely wiped them out?

A study was done by Kushner and Hovel (2006) to the response of native predators (gastropod Pteropurpura festiva) to an invasive marine bivalve, the Asian mussel Musculista senhousia (Mollusca: Bivalvia: Mytilidae). The results of the study suggested that in overall, "intertidal or subtidal areas with high seagrass cover and high predator abundance may be resistant to invasion by Asian mussels, but the likelihood that a population of M. senhousia will become established will depend on the relative densities of predator and prey, M. senhousia settlement and growth rates, and the spatial and temporal scale being considered."

The study by Kushner and Hovel (2006) also stated that "native predators may be able to confer invasion resistance to local communities, but are unlikely to be able to control large, established M. senhousia populations"


Similar to the native gastropod Pteropurpura festiva from Kushner and Hovel (2006), many of the drills (Thais sp.) were once found on top of the mussel beds.


And the eggs of the drills were also present on the surface of the mussel beds.

It is possible that the predation of the drills on the mussels could have slowly but surely led to the elimination of the mussels from the mussel bed. Though Kushner and Hovel (2006) stated that it is difficult to control large populations, the seemingly shrinking of the mussel beds observed in May could be a factor that aided the predation of the Asian mussels which led to control and thus elimination.

Nevertheless, the real reason behind such an elimination is difficult to account for. A better knowledge of the relative densities of predator and prey, M. senhousia settlement and growth rates, and their spatial and temporal scale will be needed to give a scientific explanation.


There are many sand dollars towards the northern sandbar that are teeming on the sand.


Some of the tubes from the tubeworms were also photographed. This one is the bigger one.


And there is another type of tubeworms that are much smaller.


There were about less than ten carpet anemones starting to be found growing at the sandbar. Before the mass death, the sandbar was filled with these carpet anemones like landmines.

Hopefully with time, more of these carpet anemones will return to the sand bars.


The seagrass lagoon has yet another surprise for us, another juvenile knobbly sea star! Ria has also found two of them in July as well. This is heartening.


Underside of the juvenile knobbly sea star.

And for the finale....

Common sea stars (Archaster typicus) are still around!

However, they seem to be only found at a specific spot that I always return to search for them through GPS. I hope there are more elsewhere that we have no chance to stumble across because Chek Jawa is too large to properly do a search.
All too soon, the tide still had to return and we left the shore promptly.

My friends couldn't resist climbing the Jejawi viewing tower and it was a good opportunity to take a group photo of them. Thank you all for your help today!

A more light hearted post with other sightings during the trip: http://wondercreation.blogspot.com/2008/08/chek-jawa-check-with-friends.html

Reference:
Kushner, R.B. and Hovel, K.A. (2006) Effects of native predators and eelgrass habitat structure on the introduced Asian mussel Musculista senhousia (Benson in Cantor) in southern California. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 332(2): 166-177.

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

Talk on "Life and Death at Chek Jawa" at IYOR launch



Lauded for its high biodiversity with six distinct ecosystems, Chek Jawa received a ten year deferment from land reclamation in 2001 and has subsequently become a popular attraction among Singaporeans. However, a mass death of several marine animals occurred in January 2007. A study was later done to understand what contributed to the mass mortality event and evaluate the recovery of marine animals. It is true that a better understanding is essential to protect this fascinating shore. In this talk, Kok Sheng will share with the audience how is Chek Jawa faring and also his experiences and discoveries from the study.

About the speaker: Kok Sheng is currently an undergraduate in NUS, majoring in Life Sciences with specialization in Biology. In July 2007, he received the MOE Teaching Award. Kok Sheng has great interests in ecological work and did an UROPS (Undergraduate Research Opportunities Programme in Science) project under the supervision of N. Sivasothi, Peter Todd and Dan Rittschof. His project aimed to study the mass mortality and recruitment of macrofauna at Chek Jawa in Pulau Ubin. Since the project has application value in understanding and conserving the Singapore macrofauna at Chek Jawa, Kok Sheng's project has been featured in Protecting nature's beauty in The Straits Times (September 10, 2007), Embracing Passion Going Places, the NUS Advertorial in The Straits Times (March 25, 2008) and Tuesday Report: Children Of The Earth on Channel 8, Mediacorp TV (July 8, 2008). Kok Sheng is also a volunteer with TeamSeagrass, Naked Hermit Crabs and Raffles Museum of Biodiversity Research. He also runs the Chek Jawa Mortality and Recruitment Project blog and God's Wonderful Creation blog.

Date: 9 Aug- National Day (Sat)

Time: 10.30am

Venue: Function Hall, Botany Centre, Singapore Botanic Gardens (above Taman Serasi foodcourt), more about getting there.

Contact: iyor08singapore@gmail.com



More talks, events and fun during the International Year of the Reef (IYOR) launch here: http://iyor08singapore.blogspot.com/2008/07/9-aug-sat-reef-celebrations-launch-of.html

Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Chek Jawa after four months

Following yesterday's post focusing on mainly button shells, sand stars and other marine animals, this post is a continuation on the other groups of animals that we have been monitoring. It has been four months since effort was taken to check the health of Chek Jawa properly.


As I entered the entrance of the sand bar, the first thing that caught my attention was the increase in the density and number of tubeworms. I remember the sand bar was quite barren last year.


Immediately, I went to check the anemone number 25 just beside the floating pontoon. Glad its still there but it doesn't look as green as it used to be. Instead it looks pale.


This photo was the last documentation we had of the exact anemone (number 25). This was taken by Ria Tan during January 2008. It shows a darker green coloration on the oral disk.


Many other anemones were also pale-looking as well. What caused this? Could it be the higher temperature in the weather this period? Could it be similar to the coral bleaching in Sentosa since carpet anemones also harbour zooxanthallae?


An interesting sight where a large volute shell is stuck to the mouth of the small carpet anemone. Could it be feeding a volute snail? I turned a bit to check, there was a striped hermit crab inside. Not sure if the hermit crab will survive hiding in the shell in the end.


Nevertheless, some anemones seem to be doing well. Yikang showed me this anemone which looks healthy in terms of colour and its size is humungeous.


Two-15cm rulers cannot even cover its diameter. It is about 35-40cm in diameter. Wow!


Now over to the peacock anemones. They seem to be doing okay.


The area where we used to survey peacock anemones still thrives with several of them. Can you see them from this photo.


The first photo of this collage is not a peacock anemone but I added it in since it is part of the previous photo.


How about sand dollars? They are doing very well mostly at the northern sand bar. Can you see the circular outlines?


A closer look reveals several sand dollar outlines and their movement.


They come in various sizes and cover a dense area of the sand bar.


How the sand dollars look like after removing the top sand.


This sand dollar is quite large as you can see with the hand of Yikang as a scale.


Ron who was guiding all along with Ubin volunteers told me that common sea stars were not spotted since the last time I did during January 2008. I believe their population has badly been depleted since the mass death. These common sea stars remaining are likely to be survival of the mass mortality event. Dr Lane suggested that they could have burrowed deep down to avoid the freshwater influx.

Good thing is that I have the GPS location of the isolated patch where common sea stars were last sighted. We took quite some time to search but to no avail. Finally I saw a star shaped thing with most part already burrowed. It is the common sea star and there's two, they were pseudo-copulating.


This is one of them.


And another one of the common sea star. Glad they are still around.

According to Run et al. (1988), the spawning season of these sea stars is in late June and July. So let's hope they will be back in larger numbers soon.


Last but definitely not the least, I went to check out the mussel beds. The mussel beds are fascinating because they were not around before the mass death. The conditions after the mass death created a niche for them to colonize since they are known to be invasive.


What intrigues me is that the huge patches of mussel beds moved westwards towards the high shore area. Can you see the patches nearer to the solitary sonneratia tree?


And more patches can be found nearer to the boardwalk and the rocks.


Though I didn't have the manpower to walk the boundaries with a GPS set, the estimated blue dotted part of the map shows the transition of these mussel beds westward. The maroon red parts are where the mussel beds were during January 2008.

Why did they move towards the higher shore direction. Well, we know that they like lower salinity. Could it be because the salinity seaward has higher and they prefer to be nearer to the high shore where there is a release of freshwater from the coastal forest or mangroves especially after a rain? This is a hypothesis.


Another discovery will be that these mussels have grown! They are about 2cm in length while those that I found in August last year were about 1cm in length.

I wonder if the sand stars eat these mussels to survive since button shells are now not around till later.

There's so much to learn from Chek Jawa given that it is really dynamic. Constant checking is important for us to understand the shore better and learn new things out from it. Let's hope the next check will reveal Chek Jawa to be recovering even better.

Reference:
Run, J. Q., C. P. Chen, K. H. Chang, and F. S. Chia. (1988). Mating behavior and reproductive cycle of Archaster typicus(Echinodermata: Asteroidea). Marine Biology 99: 247-253.